Pros and Cons of Annuities: An Honest Look
Annuities can turn savings into guaranteed income and protect money from market drops. They also lock money up, cap your upside and come with tax rules you need to understand. Here’s both sides, for fixed (MYGA) and fixed indexed annuities.
- Independent broker
- Multiple carriers
- CA License #0D42517
The biggest downsides
Most annuity regret comes from these three. Understand them before you sign.
Your money is tied up
Most contracts charge a surrender fee if you take out more than the free-withdrawal amount during the surrender period, often several years. A surrender charge can mean getting back less than you put in.
Your upside is limited
Fixed annuities pay a set rate. Fixed indexed annuities limit gains with caps, participation rates or spreads, and the insurer can usually change those at renewal.
Taxes come later, not never
Growth is tax-deferred, not tax-free. Earnings are taxed as ordinary income when withdrawn, and withdrawals before age 59½ can trigger a 10% federal penalty.
What annuities do well
Protection from market losses
Fixed and fixed indexed annuities don’t lose value when the stock market falls. Surrender charges can still reduce what you receive if you leave early.
A guaranteed rate (MYGA)
A multi-year guaranteed annuity locks in an interest rate for a set term, often 3 to 10 years, much like a CD issued by an insurer.
Income you can’t outlive
You can turn savings into lifetime income for you, or for you and your spouse, no matter how long you live.
Tax-deferred growth
You don’t pay tax on earnings until you withdraw them, so more of your money compounds in the meantime.
No IRS contribution limit
Unlike an IRA or 401(k), a non-qualified annuity has no annual IRS contribution cap. Insurers set their own maximums.
California senior protections
If you’re 60 or older, California gives you at least 30 days to review and return a new annuity contract.
Other things to weigh
- Inflation erodes fixed income over a long retirement unless you plan for it
- Guarantees rely on the insurer. California’s guarantee association covers 80% of an annuity’s present value, up to $250,000, if an insurer fails
- Income and other riders usually carry annual fees
- Fixed indexed annuities are complex. Read how interest is credited before you buy
- Annuities inside an IRA don’t add tax deferral. They still follow required minimum distribution rules
MYGA or fixed indexed?
The two most common fixed annuities, in one line each:
- MYGA: a set rate for a set term. Simple and predictable
- Fixed indexed: interest tied to an index, with a cap and a floor
- Both: protected from market losses, with surrender charges
- MYGA suits CD-style savers
- Fixed indexed suits people who want some upside and can accept limits
Not sure an annuity is right for you?
Sometimes the honest answer is no. Tell us your goals and we’ll tell you whether an annuity fits, and compare insurers if it does.
Annuity questions
Are annuities a good investment?
It depends on what you need. Annuities are insurance contracts, best at protecting principal and creating guaranteed income. They’re a poor fit for money you may need soon or for maximum growth. Many people use them for part of their savings, not all of it.
Can I lose money in a fixed or fixed indexed annuity?
Not from market drops. You can lose money by surrendering early, because surrender charges, and on some contracts a market value adjustment, can reduce what you get back.
How are annuity withdrawals taxed?
For a non-qualified annuity, withdrawals generally come from earnings first and are taxed as ordinary income. Withdrawals before age 59½ may also face a 10% federal penalty. Annuities held in an IRA follow IRA tax rules. Ask a tax professional about your situation.
Do annuities in an IRA have required minimum distributions?
Yes. Under SECURE 2.0, RMDs start at age 73 for most people today, and at 75 for people who turn 74 after 2032.
What happens if the insurance company fails?
Guarantees depend on the insurer’s claims-paying ability. In California, the Life & Health Insurance Guarantee Association protects 80% of an annuity’s present value, up to $250,000, subject to its rules.
Can I change my mind after buying?
If you’re 60 or older, California law gives you at least 30 days from delivery to return an annuity contract. Other buyers get the free-look period stated in the contract.
Sources: California Insurance Code §10127.10 (30-day free look for buyers age 60+); California Life & Health Insurance Guarantee Association FAQ (annuity protection of 80% of present value up to $250,000); IRS and Treasury final RMD regulations under SECURE 2.0 (RMD age 73, rising to 75 for those who turn 74 after 2032); SEC Investor Bulletin: Indexed Annuities. Annuities are insurance products, not bank deposits, and are not FDIC insured. Guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurer. Surrender charges and a 10% federal tax penalty may apply to early withdrawals. This page is general information, not tax or legal advice; talk with a tax professional about your situation.
Integrity Now Insurance Brokers, Inc.
6285 East Spring Street, Suite 457
Long Beach, CA 90808
(562) 606-1030
[email protected]
CA License #0D42517